We rented Capote just as soon as it came out on DVD. I'd seen it in theatrical release; Ben had not. What I remembered from my two solitary hours in the silent art house – I was the only person in the audience! – besides Philip Seymour Hoffman's amazing performance (yada yada yada) was how true the film seemed to me to be to a creative process that I can only describe as channeling.
Now, not all writing is channeling. In fact, most writing is not channeling. And most people whose livelihood depends on spinning content not only don't channel but look with some disdain upon channeling as the province of really bad writing books, Not Me But the Wind That Blows Through Me, Writing From the Pancreas and other titles of that ilk.
Writing from the outside in is craft, and I daresay most readers don't know the difference. There's isn't any difference in quality, even on the level of archetypal resonance, when you have a writer with chops who knows status detail, beats, story arc and the glue that goes between.
Writing from the inside out is a kind of madness. Not to go all Joseph Campbell on you, but it's the hero's journey.
It's an odd thing but the only writers who are interested in channeling are rank amateurs and the rare genius. First of all, there are few commercial markets for material that is larger than its author since we live in a culture where ego is currency. But secondly, it's an alchemical process that depletes the creator. It's a deal with the devil where you're the guy with the pitchfork, the contract, the blood it's signed in and the 100 million dollar pay-off simultaneously. Very few people are strong enough to survive it.
Capote certainly wasn't.
Watching the movie at home let me pay closer attention to the details. It really is a subtle thing to pull off in a movie! All those practically motionless landscape shots: if you look closely enough, there is always one thing – and only one thing – moving. A train, a car, a wind-tossed branch. This is the writer's imagination at work, plundering the landscape one detail at a time. The many shots of Capote watching, observing. The campy seduction of source material that came to him disguised as random strangers; the total identification with the central character – so much stronger and creepier than "falling in love."
The hard part, of course, is getting through the inevitable ego disintegration when this kind of project is through.
Capote couldn't.
Still, he produced one perfect book, In Cold Blood.
Of course, the big question is whether he might not have produced it anyway had he not insisted upon going mad behind it.
I don't know.
Now, not all writing is channeling. In fact, most writing is not channeling. And most people whose livelihood depends on spinning content not only don't channel but look with some disdain upon channeling as the province of really bad writing books, Not Me But the Wind That Blows Through Me, Writing From the Pancreas and other titles of that ilk.
Writing from the outside in is craft, and I daresay most readers don't know the difference. There's isn't any difference in quality, even on the level of archetypal resonance, when you have a writer with chops who knows status detail, beats, story arc and the glue that goes between.
Writing from the inside out is a kind of madness. Not to go all Joseph Campbell on you, but it's the hero's journey.
It's an odd thing but the only writers who are interested in channeling are rank amateurs and the rare genius. First of all, there are few commercial markets for material that is larger than its author since we live in a culture where ego is currency. But secondly, it's an alchemical process that depletes the creator. It's a deal with the devil where you're the guy with the pitchfork, the contract, the blood it's signed in and the 100 million dollar pay-off simultaneously. Very few people are strong enough to survive it.
Capote certainly wasn't.
Watching the movie at home let me pay closer attention to the details. It really is a subtle thing to pull off in a movie! All those practically motionless landscape shots: if you look closely enough, there is always one thing – and only one thing – moving. A train, a car, a wind-tossed branch. This is the writer's imagination at work, plundering the landscape one detail at a time. The many shots of Capote watching, observing. The campy seduction of source material that came to him disguised as random strangers; the total identification with the central character – so much stronger and creepier than "falling in love."
The hard part, of course, is getting through the inevitable ego disintegration when this kind of project is through.
Capote couldn't.
Still, he produced one perfect book, In Cold Blood.
Of course, the big question is whether he might not have produced it anyway had he not insisted upon going mad behind it.
I don't know.